Read this before you potentially talk yourself out of your big idea.
We've all heard the stories. Michael Jordan missed more than 9,000 shots in his career. James Dyson built 5,127 prototypes before his bagless vacuum worked. Thomas Edison famously said he found 10,000 ways that didn't work. Great stories of incredible grit, determination, and dedication.
We know that success almost always involves failures along the way. But a reminder that someone extraordinary failed and then triumphed rarely moves us if we are hesitating to act on our big goals, ideas and dreams.
If you’re lying awake wondering what happens if you spend $10,000 launching a business and only three people sign up, how much does that story help?
When it’s your big idea, and you’re still at the beginning, it’s your money, your time and possibly your pride on the line.
What helps is getting specific about the fears getting in the way – and being just as specific about what doing nothing will cost you. First, let’s look at why the fear shows up.
Why fear of failure shows up
Having a fear of failure is our brain doing its job. It’s not a flaw, it's protecting us.
We’re wired to avoid loss. A potential loss can loom larger than an equivalent gain. Psychologists call it loss aversion. A bold step puts something on the line - money, time, reputation.
It's rarely about the failure itself. It’s what we think it might mean. What will people think? Will I look foolish? It’s the potential impact on our identity and our self-esteem. The shame that we might feel. That’s a powerful deterrent.
Old lessons run deep. Early on many of us learned early that mistakes were punished, at school, at home. Plenty of workplaces still reward not getting it wrong over getting it right. The messaging is simple: don’t fail.
Uncertainty feels dangerous. Anything new is full of unknowns, and our minds tend to fill the blanks with worst cases (and we stop there). Doing nothing feels safe. It might not even feel like a decision, so its consequences don’t register as risks.
Having the fear is completely normal. What we want to avoid is letting it create an invisible prison.
How fear of failure shows up
Fear of failure can have various disguises, to the point that we may not even realise it is what’s holding us back.
Waiting for the right time. When the kids are older, when work calms down, when the market picks up. The right time keeps moving.
Endless preparation and perfectionism. One more course, one more certification, one more round of research before you're "ready". And if it can't be done brilliantly, it's not worth starting. They’re both delaying tactics.
Keeping it quiet. If nobody knows about the dream, there’s no accountability, and nobody is aware you’re not following it. It stays a secret.
Busyness. Full days of work, family and commitments that lead to “I just don’t have the time…”
Sounding sensible. "It's just not practical." "I'm being realistic." Sometimes that's true, but there might be unexplored ways around it.
The giveaway is a pattern - that big idea or big dream keeps coming back to you, like an itch in your brain. But you keep finding another reason to give it a bit longer.
So, what can we do?
Before we dig into the solution – a question for you – have you actually looked at what’s involved in achieving your big idea? And how long might it take? If you haven’t, that’s your first step – find out what’s involved and what the first few steps might involve.
Shine a light on the fear
Fear flourishes in vagueness – a broad discomfort you’d rather not look at. The answer is to treat it like any other risk and use three steps: Identify, Assess, Manage.
1. Identify: get specific
What’s worst case?
What exactly am I afraid will happen? Not “it won’t work”, but “I’ll spend $10,000 on the launch and only three people will sign up.”
What would failure actually look like? Most of us never define it, so it stays limitless. Give it edges: three sign-ups, $10,000 gone, and a launch I have to explain to friends.
What would that mean to me? This is the layer underneath. Would the hardest part be losing the money, telling people how it went, or wondering whether there’s a market at all?
2. Assess: get realistic
How likely is that worst case? Is it reversible?
Have you tested anything yet, or is “three people” a guess?
How easy would it be to reverse? If the launch flops, could you keep the website, the content and the contacts, and try again differently?
How big is the loss, really? $10,000 hurts. But those three people could tell you exactly what to change. The worst case might leave you roughly where you are now – with more experience and better information.
3. Manage: get prepared
What could you do to prevent the worst case, or shrink it? What experiment could you run?
Test demand before you spend big. Start with a pilot for $500.
Talk to people already doing it. Ask what they wish they’d known.
Keep your income steady while you start on the side.
Set a cap – a budget or a time limit you won’t go past.
Build the specific skill the fear is pointing at.
This is based on the risk management approach from my corporate days. The first time I applied it to a personal project, my Nile expedition, I was blown away by how a difference it made – there was so much that terrified me. Running through this process gave me the confidence to take action.
Shining a light on a fear takes away some of its power. A vague fear gives you nothing to work with. A specific fear is a problem – and a problem is something you can solve.
What’s the cost of inaction?
Staying put can feel safe, but it's not a free choice because we're letting fear make the decision. We focus on the potential downside of taking action but rarely picture, in the same detail, what staying put will cost us. We might tell ourselves that by not acting, by waiting til the time is right, we avoid risk. We don't. We swap one set of risks for another.
Listening to Tim Ferriss’ podcast the other day, he reshared part of his ‘fear-setting exercise’ that tackles exactly this.
Take a piece of paper and create three columns: six months, one year and three years (or push the timeline out if that’s more helpful). Under each, list the things that not acting on your idea will mean. What happens if life stays the same? You might consider it from an emotional perspective, financial, physical – whatever matters to you.
Be honest, and again, be specific. "I'll feel a bit flat" isn't enough. "I'll be another year older, still in the same role and frustrated” is.
For the $10,000 launch, the three-year column might read: Still in a job I’ve outgrown. Still wondering whether anyone would have bought it. Someone else has launched something similar. Put that next to the $10,000 and see which one scares you more.
Picture yourself a year from now, still thinking about the idea. What would you wish you’d found out by then? Is there a small way to find that out this week?
Your next step
You don't need to have the whole idea planned out. You don't need Michael Jordan's story. Just decide on the next step. Make it small, simple, time-limited and easy to undo.
What’s yours? Write it down and put a date next to it.
Sarah